On September 27, 1917, some of baseball’s greatest stars descended on Fenway Park for a game that has largely disappeared from the sport’s collective memory.
Babe Ruth, Ty Cobb, Shoeless Joe Jackson, Walter Johnson, Tris Speaker and others came together not for a pennant or championship, but to honor Tim Murnane — a former player, manager and baseball executive who became one of the sport’s most influential early journalists. After Murnane died suddenly that February, leaving behind a wife, six young children and significant debts, baseball rallied around his family.
The result was the Tim Murnane Memorial Benefit Game, an extraordinary afternoon featuring the powerhouse Boston Red Sox against a hand-picked team of stars from both major leagues. Players left their own teams during the season and traveled to Boston at their own expense. Before the first pitch came skills competitions that look remarkably familiar today: a home run derby, throwing contests and a race around the bases. Will Rogers rode onto the field on horseback, Fanny Brice hawked programs in the stands, and former heavyweight champion John L. Sullivan coached first base.
Author Scott Reich joins us to discuss his book "One Day in September: Baseball, Brotherhood, and the Birth of the All-Star Game," which resurrects Murnane’s remarkable life and makes the case that this forgotten gathering provided a blueprint for baseball’s modern All-Star Game — sixteen years before the first official Midsummer Classic.
Along the way, Reich takes us inside baseball’s unruly formative decades, explains how Murnane became one of the game’s most trusted voices, and explores what this remarkable afternoon revealed about the sport in 1917 — when ballparks doubled as civic gathering places and baseball’s biggest stars could put pennant races aside for a cause larger than the game.